It's becoming apparent that many people are confusing a "smokey" look with something it really isnt. It seems as though everyone has their own perception of what a true smokey eye really is.
A true smokey eye has any colored lid (usually dark), that extends into the crease, as well as under the eye. It is darkest along the lashline and fades up and out. A smokey eye is NOT a lighter lid, with a deeper crease. That is simply a basic standard way to place shadows.
"smokey" is a technique, and not just the fact that you're using darker shades.
Some pics to help:
all the pictures on the right hand side are pictures that the girls who created the look mislabeled as "smokey"
*please note* i am NOT claiming these pictures as my own work. I am simply using them as references, examples, and for education. All the images are from other bloggers, and are all beautifully done.*
...smokey... ...pretty, but not smokey....
credit: the lovely Temptalia
credit: smokeyeyetutorial.net
...smokey... ...totally stunning, but not smokey...
credit: April J0 (her flickr name)
credit: MissCaseyB.com.
...smokey (and AWESOME!) ...gorgeous, but not smokey...
credit: sunnishinee (her Youtube name)
credit: promakeupbrushes.co.uk
and some of my own pics...
...smokey... ...not smokey...


as I mentioned earlier, putting a darker color in the crease is just standard shadow placement! Please don't get it confused with smokey
Hope this helped!